Skip to Main Content
Services Talent Knowledge
Site Search


Our attorneys stay on top of changes in legislation, agency regulations, case law, and industry trends—then craft timely legal alerts to keep clients up to date on legal developments important to their business.

July 2, 2010

Severe Sanctions Imposed for Failure to Preserve, Collect and Produce Electronic Discovery

In a recent decision from the Southern District of New York, Judge Shira Scheindlin imposed sanctions as a result of careless and indifferent document collection efforts, raising the bar for parties to preserve, collect and produce electronically stored information. The decision, Pension Committee of the University of Montreal Pension Plan v. Banc of America Securities, LLC, et al., 2010 U.S. Dist. LEXIS 4546 (S.D.N.Y. Jan. 15, 2010), comes six years after Judge Scheindlin's ground breaking Zubulake decisions. See, e.g., Zubulake v. UBS Warburg LLC, 229 F.R.D. 422 (S.D.N.Y. 2004).

In February 2004, the plaintiffs in Montreal Pension brought an action in the Southern District of New York claiming violations of federal securities laws and New York law. At the time the action was commenced, the plaintiffs' attorneys requested that the plaintiffs collect documents related to their claims, including electronic documents. The requests did not, however, include specific instructions that the plaintiffs should refrain from deleting or destroying records, nor were the requests accompanied by written litigation hold letters, which were not formally issued until 2007.

During the discovery process, several defendants claimed to have found substantial gaps in plaintiffs' document productions. After the close of discovery, defendants moved for sanctions, alleging that several plaintiffs not only failed to preserve and produce documents but also submitted false and misleading declarations regarding their document collection and preservation efforts.

In her decision, Judge Scheindlin ruled that the plaintiffs targeted by the discovery motion fell into two categories – negligent or grossly negligent. She concluded the plaintiffs had either lost or destroyed documents based on the scarcity of the documents produced, the admitted failure to preserve records after the duty to preserve arose, and in some instances the failure to search for records at all. She then imposed monetary sanctions on both the negligent and grossly negligent parties, and awarded attorneys' fees to the innocent parties for the additional discovery conducted regarding spoliation of evidence. Judge Scheindlin also agreed to instruct the jury that, as to the grossly negligent plaintiffs, the jury could infer the missing documents were relevant to the defendants' case and would have been prejudicial to the offending plaintiffs. The decision highlights the need for vigilance with respect to the collection and retention of a party's relevant documents once litigation is foreseeable.

If you require further information regarding the information presented in this Legal Alert and its impact on your organization, please contact any of the members of the Practice Area.


Click here to sign up for alerts, blog posts, and firm news.

Featured Media


US Supreme Court Shrinks Federal Authority Under the Clean Water Act


Supreme Court Strikes Down Taxing Authorities' Right to Retain Surplus Monies in "Strict Foreclosures"


Appellate Division, Third Department, Denies Appeal and Upholds Office of Renewable Energy Siting Regulations


NYS Public Service Commission Formally Initiates Proceeding to Establish What Constitutes "Zero Emission" Under the CLCPA


NYS Appellate Court Dismisses Common Law Claims Against Contractor for Injuries Sustained by "Special Employee"


Child Victim Act Complaint Dismissed for Failure to Sufficiently Allege Special Duty

This site uses cookies to give you the best experience possible on our site and in some cases direct advertisements to you based upon your use of our site.

By clicking [I agree], you are agreeing to our use of cookies. For information on what cookies we use and how to manage our use of cookies, please visit our Privacy Statement.

I AgreeOpt-Out