Skip to Main Content
Services Talent Knowledge
Site Search


Our attorneys stay on top of changes in legislation, agency regulations, case law, and industry trends—then craft timely legal alerts to keep clients up to date on legal developments important to their business.

October 26, 2021

Fourth Department Distinguishes Medical Malpractice From Ordinary Negligence in Nursing Home Case

In its October 1, 2021, decision in Noga v. Brothers of Mercy Nursing & Rehabilitation Ctr.1, the Appellate Division, Fourth Department modified the order of the Supreme Court, Erie County that granted the plaintiff leave to reargue, denied the nursing home defendants’ motion for summary judgment, and reversed the order dismissing the complaint. In its decision, the Fourth Department determined that some of the plaintiff’s causes of action alleging medical malpractice and negligence against the nursing home should have been dismissed.

In Noga, the decedent’s estate filed suit against the nursing home defendants seeking damages for the decedent’s physical injuries and ultimate death, alleging negligence after the decedent, a double amputee resident of the nursing home, fell from his wheelchair while left unsupervised, sustained a left shoulder fracture, and died two days later.  

The Fourth Department determined that the plaintiff’s claims alleging failures relative to the appropriateness of services rendered to the decedent, adequacy of staffing, and adequacy of preparing a care plan sounded in medical malpractice “because they challenged the defendants’ assessment of the decedent’s need for supervision.” It further concluded that the nursing home’s motion should have been granted with respect to the plaintiff’s claims sounding in medical malpractice except for those claims relating to proper supervision and the failure to revise the decedent’s care plan.  

Regarding the plaintiff’s claims that the nursing home defendants were negligent in “failing to follow the care plan and to equip the decedent’s wheelchair with a seatbelt,” the Fourth Department held these claims sounded in ordinary negligence “as they relate[d] to the defendants’ general duty to safeguard the nursing home residents. . . .” It further determined that the lower court should have granted the defendants’ motion with respect to the claim for failure to equip the decedent’s wheelchair with a seatbelt, finding that the plaintiff expert failed to opine how a nonrestrictive lap belt would have prevented the accident. However, the Fourth Department concluded that the lower court appropriately denied the nursing home defendants’ motion with respect to the claim involving the care plan, noting that the nursing home defendants’ papers demonstrated the decedent was left unsupervised for a period longer than permitted by his care plan.  

The Noga decision is an example of how courts must analyze claims for medical malpractice using different criteria than when analyzing claims sounding in ordinary negligence.

If you have any questions regarding the content of this alert, please contact Elizabeth Vulaj, associate, at; Tara Sciortino, counsel, at; Matthew Larkin, Torts & Products Liability Defense Practice Area chair, at; Tom Cronmiller, Professional Liability Practice Area chair, at; or another member of the firm’s Torts & Products Liability Defense or Professional Liability Practice Areas. 

Featured Media


NYS Siting Board Grants Developer's Petition for Relief From County's Unreasonable Delay


Horseback Rider Assumes Risk of "Green Broke" Horse


New York Adult Survivors Act Set to Expire


NYS Appellate Court Reverses in Favor of Policyholder in Ensuing Loss Case


Temporary Health Care Staffing Agencies Can No Longer Charge for Hiring Their Personnel


The First Department Addresses When a Party Is Entitled to Treble Damages Pursuant to Judiciary Law §487

This site uses cookies to give you the best experience possible on our site and in some cases direct advertisements to you based upon your use of our site.

By clicking [I agree], you are agreeing to our use of cookies. For information on what cookies we use and how to manage our use of cookies, please visit our Privacy Statement.

I AgreeOpt-Out